3P Protect Perryman Peninsula Files Lawsuit

On February 1, 2023, an amended complaint was filed in the Circuit Court for Harford County. The amended complaint added defendant Charles Maslin who owns the property the developer plans to use for project ingress and egress. The complaint also adds language to incorporate the latest round of plans submitted by the developer which escalate the intensity of the project. Finally, the amended complaint adds facts to support plaintiff claims for damages. 

On June 7, 2022, 3P Protect Perryman Peninsula, LLC. along with 6 other plaintiffs brought suit against F.O. Mitchell & Bro. Inc., Chesapeake Real Estate Group LLC, Frederick Ward Associates Inc. and Harford County, Maryland.

Citing plans for an illegal freight terminal 3P and the other named plaintiffs have brought suit alleging an inexplicable violation of Harford County zoning laws in addition to both public and private nuisance.  The lawsuit, filed in Circuit Court for Anne Arundel County comes after nearly six months of working unsuccessfully with both the Glassman administration in the Harford County Executive Branch and the Harford County Councilmen Pat Vincenti and Curtis Beulah in the Legislative Branch. The lawsuit seeks to save the property values and protect the ownership interests of the other 1200 people who live on the peninsula with the Mitchells.

Read Full Amended Complaint (PDF)

Latest Litigation Updates

Case Number:

  • Harford County C-12-CV-22-000888 OPEN
  • Anne Arundel County C-02-CV-22-000988 CLOSED

Upcoming Dates:

  • No scheduled events

Litigation Documents:

02-01-2023 Amended Complaint
  • 2023.02.01 Verified Amended Complaint – Verified Amended Complaint for Injunctive Relief and Declaratory Judgement and Private Action for Nuisance and Public Nuisance, with Compensatory Damages

Circuit Court for Anne Arundel County’s order to transfer the case to Harford County:

Defendants expert witness filings:

Defendant, Frederick Ward Associates, Inc. files motion to join defendant Harford County’s reply in support of motion to dismiss.

Defendant Harford County, Maryland files motion to reply in support of motion to dismiss.

Plaintiffs (including 3P) file opposition to the motions to dismiss by the defendants.

Defendant Chesapeake Real Estate Group, LLC (CREG) files motion to dismiss and request for a hearing.

Meet the Plantiffs

Thank you to our fellow community members for standing up for justice and demonstrating courage in this most important moment for the Perryman Peninsula. We salute you! 

“Courage is resistance to fear, mastery of fear, not absence of fear.” ~Mark Twain

Paul Cisar

Paul Cisar is a resident of Harford County who lives adjacent to the Mitchell Property with his wife and three children. He has been a resident at that location since 1994.

Sarah Gonzalez

Sarah Gonzalez is a resident of Harford County who lives adjacent to the Mitchell property with her husband and has been a resident of that location since 2022.

Justin Pickering

Justin Pickering is a resident of Harford County who lives adjacent to the Mitchell Property with his wife and two children. He has been a resident at that location since 2016.

Norma Tilton

Norma Tilton is a resident of Harford County who lives adjacent to the Mitchell Property with her husband. She has been a resident at that location since 1993.

Tamie Wainwright

Tamie Wainwright is a resident of Harford County who lives in proximity to the Mitchell Property with her husband and son. She has been a resident at that location since 2017.

Shawn Warnick

Shawn Warnick is a resident of Harford County who lives adjacent to the Mitchell Property. He has been a resident at that location since 2019.

About Our Litigation Firm

Baldwin | Seraina, LLC

Baldwin | Seraina is a litigation firm with office locations in Baltimore and Annapolis. The firm is built on a tradition of excellence, going back nearly 40 years.

Rignal W. Baldwin V

Rignal Baldwin’s litigation experience includes civil rights, administrative law, construction law, business litigation and wrongful death/personal injury. He is passionate about the rule of law and representing individuals affected by government overreach.

Rig has successfully represented individual and companies in lawsuits relating to official misconduct, business disputes, academic disputes and administrative matters.

Learn more

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *